ISLAMABAD — The Islamabad High Court has disposed of a writ petition challenging the official sealing of the Bari Imam House in Nurpur Shahan, instructing the petitioner to present documented proof of ownership directly to the Capital Development Authority (CDA). In a judgment authored by Justice Ayyaz Shaukat, the court declined to grant the declaratory relief sought by Muhammad Akmal, who serves as the caretaker of the premises located opposite the prominent shrine of Bari Imam Sarkar.
The legal challenge stemmed from an operation conducted on October 30, wherein the CDA and the Islamabad Capital Territory administration jointly sealed the premises. According to the civic authority, the structure represents an unauthorized encroachment on government land that was formally acquired under Award No. 4/DC CDA in 1963, with historical compensation duly disbursed to the original landowners. The CDA stated that the affected property spans specific Khasras and does not feature any officially recognized structure designated as the Bari Imam House in its baseline records.
Conversely, the petitioner asserted that the disputed location comprises a mosque, a langar khana, and necessary ablution facilities, arguing that the land constitutes exempted shrine property that was never incorporated into the CDA's acquisition sweep. Furthermore, the petition alleged that the administrative sealing occurred without prior notice or a formal opportunity for a hearing, thereby breaching constitutional safeguards. During the proceedings, the petitioner's counsel acknowledged that the relevant revenue and land records remain deposited with the CDA and the district administration.
Addressing the core dispute, the bench observed that questions regarding whether the land sits on exempted shrine property or state-acquired tracts involve contested factual determinations that fall outside the purview of constitutional jurisdiction based solely on unverified assertions. Rather than ruling on the substantive merits, the court directed the petitioner to submit any available ownership papers to the CDA within five days. The civic authority has subsequently been mandated to grant a formal hearing and evaluate the documentation in accordance with the law.
